UPS Batteries Trigger Repeated Power Grid Frequency Drops

·

Coordinated disturbances haunt grids worldwide. Here’s how researchers solved the mystery.

A research team led by Dirk Witthaut at Germany’s Forschungszentrum Jülich identified the cause of repeated drops in power grid frequency across several countries. Internet-connected UPS units and large batteries were checking their charge status at the same time. The same pattern appeared on power grids in Europe, Australia, the United States and Malaysia.

Electrical frequency is a key measure of power grid stability. If its amplitude rises or operators respond incorrectly without identifying the cause, outages can follow. Small power fluctuations from individual UPS units are rarely detectable on a wide-area power grid. When multiple devices check their status simultaneously, however, those fluctuations accumulate and produce visible drops in frequency.

Signals of a common clock rather than hydro generator resonance

The Witthaut research team first examined the possibility of very-low-frequency oscillations originating at hydroelectric plants. A model of a Scandinavian power grid’s hydroelectric plant control system revealed resonance conditions with a peak once per minute, but this did not explain why the phenomenon persisted for long periods. Mechanical resonance generally appears and disappears, while the observed power grid frequency drops repeated without exception every 60 seconds.

The team followed the clue that such precise periodicity would require a common clock. They formed the hypothesis that many devices programmed to check battery status every minute and synchronized to internet clocks could produce the same pattern at the same time across different regions.

Evidence confirmed by more than 80 power quality meters

The research team installed more than 80 smart power quality meters at the Jülich campus. The campus had medium- and low-voltage distribution lines, transformers, solar panels and a battery energy storage system used as a UPS. The meters recorded frequency, voltage, current and power every three seconds.

Measurements showed that the transformer connected to the battery energy storage system had a peak in frequency fluctuations every minute, matching the pattern observed on the wide-area power grid. The team determined that simultaneous status checks by many stationary batteries, from data center UPS units to large grid-scale batteries, directly caused the periodic checks. Their clock synchronization resulted from their internet connections.

Additional evidence for this cause came from Irish power grid data. Data centers accounted for a substantial share of Ireland’s power load, consuming 18% of the total load in 2022. Each facility operated multiple UPS units.

Ireland’s frequency drops increased fourfold

The minute-by-minute frequency drops in Ireland increased fourfold, from 3mHz in 2016 to 12mHz in 2021. Some recent drops exceeded 20mHz. The country’s 50Hz power grid can tolerate fluctuations of plus or minus 200mHz, but operators prefer to remain within 100mHz.

Although 20mHz is not large compared with the permitted range, loads outside data centers also create frequency fluctuations. The overlap between the effects of other loads and simultaneous UPS status checks can bring a power grid closer to outage conditions, making it an important operational risk. However, the original article did not present quantitative experimental results showing how much random scheduling would reduce actual fluctuations.

Staggering UPS timing and managing IoT firmware

The research team recommended that UPS and grid-scale battery manufacturers add randomness to the timing of charge status checks rather than fixing them to the start of each minute. Reducing the number of status checks that coincide at a single time could also ease the combined fluctuations transmitted to the power grid.

The risk is also present in IoT devices. The research team detected periodic power fluctuations in various IoT devices, including smart ovens and Raspberry Pi clusters, and a simple software patch corrected them. Recent research indicates that fewer than 3% of IoT devices run the latest firmware, however, so the large number of unpatched devices requires updates to be managed for each device.

Transformer-level verification with power quality meters can identify one-minute periodic fluctuations arising from UPS units or battery storage systems. Operators can review records of transformer frequency, voltage, current and power to determine whether status checks overlap, allowing them to narrow down the affected periods.

Regulators may require IoT device firmware to remain current, but addressing the problem on one region’s power grid would be insufficient to resolve an issue occurring across multiple countries. The Witthaut research team said that a global level of coordination is needed for a final solution.

Source article

This article was written after reviewing the following source: TechCrunch, Coordinated disturbances haunt grids worldwide. Here’s how researchers solved the mystery.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *