Kim Seung-won, Justice Minister Nominee, Faces Triple Scandal — Key Issues 3 Days Before Confirmation Hearing

·

Key Summary

  • Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won stated on the 3rd, during his first visit to the confirmation hearing preparation office, that he has no intention of directing the dismissal of charges in President Lee Jae-myung’s criminal case.
  • The nominee mentioned that the Minister of Justice does not have direct authority to command the Prosecutor General on individual cases; however, under the current Prosecution Service Act and the Public Prosecution Act scheduled to take effect in October, there is a clear legal basis for the Minister of Justice to command the Prosecutor General on specific cases.
  • Nominee Kim, who served as co-chair of the “Legislative Caucus for the Dismissal of Charges in the Lee Jae-myung Presidential Case and a National Investigation” (Gongchwi-mo), has publicly advocated for charge dismissal, but explained that his remarks conveyed “the public’s position that the state should correct indictments fabricated through illegal investigation.”

This article bundles, as a political issue, the denial of charge-dismissal authority and the explanation of the new drug lobbying allegations ahead of the nominee’s confirmation hearing in three days. Meanwhile, a new controversy — the warrant-dedicated judge collusion suspicion — has been raised by former leader Han Dong-hoon, presenting a key agenda that requires verification at the hearing, making an issue-organization format appropriate.

Table of Contents

Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won drew a line on the 3rd, stating he has no intention of directing the dismissal of charges in President Lee Jae-myung’s criminal case, as he made his first visit to the confirmation hearing preparation office. At the same time, regarding the COVID-19 treatment clinical trial request allegations, he explained, “I have never done anything improper.” However, on the same day, former People Power Party leader Han Dong-hoon raised suspicions of warrant-dedicated judge collusion, meaning nominee Kim Seung-won has entered hearing D-3 carrying all three controversies at once.

The nominee’s side explains that the Minister of Justice does not have direct authority to command the Prosecutor General on individual cases. However, the current Prosecution Service Act and the Public Prosecution Act scheduled to take effect in October clearly stipulate a legal basis for the Minister of Justice to command the Prosecutor General on specific cases. Since Justice Minister Kim’s command authority operates across the entire investigation and indictment stages, the explanation that “we respect the trial prosecutor who decides whether to proceed to trial” reads as a superficial concession.

From the author’s perspective, the most concerning part is the Gongchwi-mo record. Despite being a former co-chair of the “Legislative Caucus for the Dismissal of Charges in the Lee Jae-myung Presidential Case and a National Investigation,” it appears contradictory that he explained his own remarks as conveying “the public’s position that the state should correct indictments fabricated through illegal investigation.” If he changed his position, we need to hear when and why; if he didn’t, we need to hear why he believes he can perform the duties of minister.

Kim Seung-won, Justice Minister Nominee: The Legal Contradiction in Charge-Dismissal Remarks

The fact that the Justice Minister’s command authority exists under current law has been addressed in legal literature. However, while the nominee emphasizes that “the authority to maintain charges in individual cases belongs to the trial prosecutor,” command at the investigation stage and command at the indictment decision stage are distinguished. How far confirmation hearing members probe this distinction is the first verification point. There is a large interpretive gap between the ruling and opposition parties on this matter.

New Drug Lobbying Timeline — From 2021 Request to 2024 Constitutional Complaint

In 2021, Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won was investigated on charges of intermediating bribery promises, etc., for accepting a request from acquaintance Yang Mo and asking then-Ministry of Food and Drug Safety head Kim Gang-rip to expedite approval of Genencell’s COVID-19 treatment clinical trial. In December 2024, he received a suspension of indictment from the prosecution, and filed a constitutional complaint with the Constitutional Court the same year. The nominee’s side argues the injustice, stating, “Not guilty was warranted, but the indictment was merely suspended because I introduced a fundraising method.”

Yang Mo was confirmed to have called nominee Kim “oppa” (older brother) and sent a message reading, “He’s in the Lee Jae-myung line, but since I couldn’t repay the favor, it feels awkward to ask again.” Yang requested the founder of the pharmaceutical company, Mr. Kang, “Please give a 5 million won donation to Kim, who worked hard for us.” However, since Justice Minister Kim Seung-won’s donation limit was already filled, no actual transfer took place. The nominee’s side maintains the position, “We never requested treatment approval, priority review, standard relaxation, or procedure omission, and the approval process proceeded normally.”

The amount of 5 million won is not insignificant even under the Political Funds Act. However, from a practitioner’s standpoint, the more meaningful point is that the matter ended in a suspension of indictment. The prosecution must have had a clear reason for choosing a suspension of indictment rather than a not-guilty disposition, and whether that reason will be disclosed at the hearing is the key. Reports that Yang said, “Attracting 30 billion won was easy,” have also become a new flashpoint in partisan clashes.

Han Dong-hoon Raises Allegations of Warrant-Dedicated Judge Exclusion Request Related to Justice Minister Nominee

Independent lawmaker Han Dong-hoon disclosed on this day through social media the fact that the request to exclude warrant-dedicated judge Jeong Mo from the new drug lobbying case was sent up from the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office to the Supreme Court, but was not accepted. Whether the special relationship between Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won and Yang was cited as the reason for exclusion has emerged as a key issue. It was reported that former leader Han fiercely criticized candidate Kim across 13 instances and stated his position of “special prosecutor over hearing.”

It has not yet been officially confirmed whether the warrant-dedicated judge exclusion request was actually filed with the Supreme Court. Why the Supreme Prosecutors’ Office requested exclusion and on what grounds the Supreme Court rejected it are verification points for the hearing. Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won’s side has not yet issued an official position on this allegation. People Power Party demanded the withdrawal of the nomination that day.

Issue Nominee’s Position Opposition’s Claim Hearing Verification Point
Charge Dismissal Authority “No intention to command” Command authority exists under current law, Gongchwi-mo record When and why Gongchwi-mo activities were discontinued
New Drug Lobbying “Never did anything improper” Request facts acknowledged, constitutional complaint in progress Whether actual influence was exerted on clinical trial approval
Warrant Collusion No official position issued Han Dong-hoon: “Exclusion request was made” Supreme Court filing status and reasons for rejection

The original report can be found at the related article source.

What to Do Right Now

  • Check the confirmation hearing schedule on the National Assembly website and pre-open the live broadcast channel
  • Browse the nominee Kim’s speech records and legislative activities on the Open Assembly site in advance
  • Follow former leader Han Dong-hoon’s official social media accounts to track subsequent positions on the warrant-dedicated judge
  • Check the progress of the constitutional complaint on the Constitutional Court website
  • Read the provisions related to command authority in the Prosecution Service Act and the Public Prosecution Act directly at the Prosecution Service’s legal information center

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the confirmation hearing for Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won?

It will be held as scheduled at the National Assembly’s Legislation and Judiciary Committee. The exact schedule can be confirmed through the committee’s notice, and at the time of this report, there are three days left until the hearing (D-3).

Does the Justice Minister actually have charge-dismissal command authority?

Both the current Prosecution Service Act and the Public Prosecution Act scheduled to take effect in October provide grounds for the Minister of Justice to command the Prosecutor General on specific cases. However, in practice, the trial prosecutor makes the final decision on whether to maintain or dismiss charges at trial.

Is a suspension of indictment the same as not guilty?

No. A suspension of indictment is a disposition under the Criminal Procedure Act where, although criminal suspicion is acknowledged, the indictment is suspended for reasons of criminal policy. It is distinguished from a not-guilty disposition.

What does a warrant-dedicated judge exclusion request mean?

Under the Criminal Procedure Act, it is a procedure to request a judge to be excluded from a case when there are circumstances that make it difficult to expect fair review. If accepted by the Supreme Court, another judge takes over the warrant review.

Issue Summary

What needs to be confirmed at the hearing is essentially three things. First, when and under what circumstances nominee Kim concluded his co-chair activities at Gongchwi-mo. Second, whether any actual financial benefit was received as consideration for the request in his relationship with Yang Mo. Third, whether the nominee’s circumstances were reflected in the background of the warrant-dedicated judge exclusion request. If all three are not resolved, it will be difficult to receive trust as the head of the Ministry of Justice. Ultimately, how transparently these three are addressed within the three-day hearing period is likely to be the turning point that determines the appointment of Justice Minister Kim Seung-won.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *